Insurance is the least fun part of running a Turo fleet and the fastest way to lose one. We have watched hosts run great listings for a year, then eat a five-figure loss because the car was hit on the way back from a detail — a window no personal policy and no Turo plan was covering. We buy off-trip coverage for our own cars, we have quoted every option in this article, and this is the guide we give friends who ask “so what insurance do I actually need?” The short answer: coverage lives in two windows — during trips and between them — and you need a plan for both.
Turo’s earnings-plan terms and Tint’s and Roamly’s eligibility and starting prices below are current as of October 2026: we re-checked them against Turo’s help center, the vendors’ own pages, and Finder on October 23, 2026. Tint’s 60-day GPS install window, its deductible options, and its advertised savings figure are carried over from our August 2026 check and were not re-verified. Insurers change rates and eligibility constantly — always confirm with the provider before buying. Nothing here is insurance, legal, or tax advice.
What changed in the October 23, 2026 update
- Earnings plans corrected. The three US plans are More peace of mind (70% host share, $250 damage responsibility), Balanced (80%, $1,500) and More earnings (90%, $2,750). An earlier version of this guide used “60, 75, and 90” and $0 / $250 / $2,500, which don’t match Turo’s published plans.
- Deductible and reserve strategy reworked against the real damage-responsibility amounts, with the arithmetic shown. It is still our judgment as working hosts, not advice, and the fleet-size structures changed as a result.
- Trip-window section expanded: what Turo’s reimbursement excludes, that it is a contract with Turo rather than insurance, the August 18, 2026 rule on ineligible repair facilities, and state-minimum liability for New York vehicles (since June 17, 2026).
- Vendor facts re-checked: Tint needs 3+ cars on Turo and isn’t offered in New York or Kentucky; Roamly needs 2+ cars and starts “as low as $59/month” for liability only, and its between-trip coverage works with other platforms and direct rentals, while on-rental coverage for direct rentals is a separate Roamly product. We also dropped the earlier “no deductible” and “choice of deductible options” wording for Tint, which we could not confirm.
The two windows: trip and off-trip
Every minute of your car’s life falls into one of two buckets, and a different policy is responsible for each:
- The trip window — from the moment a guest’s trip starts to the moment it ends. Turo’s earnings plan covers this window.
- The off-trip window — everything else: the car parked at home, the drive to the car wash, delivering it to the airport, test drives after a repair. Turo’s protection does not apply here, and neither does a personal policy once your carrier learns the car is a business asset.
Most new hosts obsess over the first window because Turo puts it in the signup flow, and ignore the second because nobody makes them buy it. That is exactly backwards: the trip window is handled the moment you pick a plan, while the off-trip window is a gap you have to close yourself.
During trips: your earnings plan is the coverage
Since January 7, 2026, US hosts choose one of three earnings plans, and the plan is also the trip-window protection. All three include up to $750,000 in third-party liability coverage under a policy issued to Turo by Travelers (New York vehicles have defaulted to state minimums since June 17, 2026), plus a contractual reimbursement from Turo for eligible trip-period physical damage above your damage responsibility — what you pay first on each claim. The more of the trip price you keep, the higher that amount:
| Plan | You keep | You pay first, per eligible claim |
|---|---|---|
| More peace of mind | 70% of trip price | $250 |
| Balanced | 80% of trip price | $1,500 |
| More earnings | 90% of trip price | $2,750 |
Turo reimburses eligible costs above that amount, up to the lesser of the car’s actual cash value or $200,000, and your damage responsibility is not refunded once a claim is filed. It is a contractual reimbursement, not an insurance policy. For example, on an eligible $2,000 repair you pay $250 on More peace of mind (Turo reimburses $1,750), $1,500 on Balanced ($500), and the full $2,000 on More earnings, because the claim is smaller than the $2,750 you owe first. We put more claim examples in our full breakdown of the three earnings plans — this article is about everything the earnings plan does not cover.
What it does not cover is the point: pre-existing damage, exterior wear and tear (dings, dents, and scratches of 3 inches or smaller), damage during the delivery period, mechanical failure and deterioration, personal items, certain worn tires, underbody scrapes, diminished value, loss of income while a damaged car sits in the shop, and replacement-vehicle costs. Since August 18, 2026, repairs at facilities Turo flags as ineligible aren’t reimbursed either. And — the big one — anything that happens outside the trip window. The gap between trips is where the rest of this guide lives.
Why your personal policy will not save you
Personal auto policies are priced for commuting and groceries, and nearly all of them exclude commercial use. The moment your car earns money on Turo, three bad things become possible:
- Claim denial. The carrier investigates, finds the Turo listing, and denies the off-trip claim as excluded business use. You pay the loss.
- Cancellation and non-renewal. Carriers routinely drop policyholders they discover hosting — even ones who never filed a claim. Losing your personal policy also raises rates on your household’s other cars.
- Rescission. If the carrier decides you misrepresented how the car is used, it can unwind the policy entirely — as if you were never insured.
“I just won’t tell them” is not a strategy; it is a deferred catastrophe. The honest fix costs $56–$100 per car per month: a commercial off-trip policy written for carshare hosts. In the US market, the two names every host compares are Tint and Roamly, with a local commercial broker as the third door.
Tint: Turo’s embedded partner
Tint is the off-trip product Turo itself promotes to hosts, and it is usually the cheapest way to cover a Turo-only fleet — if you qualify. As of October 2026:
- Price. Liability-only from about $56/month per car; plans that add physical damage from about $89/month, as listed by Finder — Tint’s own page now sends US hosts to a quote in the Turo host portal, so treat those as starting points. Tint advertises average savings of ~$951 per vehicle per year versus keeping personal coverage — vendor math, but directionally real, because off-trip policies price only the miles the car actually drives between trips.
- Eligibility. You need 3 or more vehicles listed on Turo, and Tint is not offered in New York or Kentucky. One- and two-car hosts are out — see Roamly and brokers below.
- Scope. Cars listed on Turo, between trips and for hosting-related use; personal driving isn’t covered. It is built around Turo hosting, so if you also rent the car directly or list it on another platform, confirm with Tint that those uses are covered before you rely on it.
- Telematics. Connect each car to an approved GPS tracker within 60 days or the car moves to a pricier non-telematics plan. Utilization is rewarded too: booking a car 60%+ of the time earns up to a 10% renewal discount.
The GPS requirement is not a nuisance — it is the discount lever. We already run trackers in every car for theft recovery and mileage truth, so Tint’s telematics rates are free money for a fleet like ours.
Roamly Carshare: the flexible one
Roamly Carshare comes out of the Outdoorsy family and sells the coverage Tint will not: smaller fleets and business use beyond Turo. As of October 2026:
- Price. “As low as $59/month” per car, for liability coverage only and varying by state. Quotes move with fleet size, vehicles, and history, so treat the floor as a floor.
- Eligibility. 2 or more vehicles, with no upper cap — Roamly markets the same product to 3-car hosts and 300-car operators.
- Scope. The reason we pay attention: its between-trip coverage works with any platform or your own direct rentals, not just Turo. If you ever plan to take bookings off-platform, this is the off-trip policy that follows the car instead of the marketplace. On-rental coverage for direct rentals is a separate Roamly product, so ask what you would actually be buying.
- Telematics. Roamly asks for a connected telematics device within 30 days, which feeds its rates, theft recovery, and weather alerts.
Roamly’s direct-rental scope has a bookkeeping side, too. If some cars earn on Turo and others on direct bookings, rental car management softwarethat handles both lets you keep one per-car P&L across channels instead of two spreadsheets.
Tint vs Roamly, side by side
Figures below are published starting points as of October 2026(Tint’s as listed by Finder, Roamly’s from its own page) — your quote will differ by state, vehicles, and history.
| Tint (Turo's partner) | Roamly Carshare | |
|---|---|---|
| Starting price | ~$56/mo per car liability-only; ~$89/mo with physical damage | from ~$59/mo per car (liability only; varies by state) |
| Minimum fleet | 3+ cars listed on Turo; not offered in New York or Kentucky | 2+ cars, no upper cap |
| Scope | Cars listed on Turo, between trips and for hosting-related use | Between-trip coverage that works with any platform or your own direct rentals; on-rental cover for direct rentals is a separate product |
| Telematics | Approved GPS within 60 days, or moved to pricier non-telematics plan | Connected device within 30 days |
| Discounts | Lowest rates on telematics plans; up to 10% renewal discount at 60%+ utilization | Varies by fleet size and history |
| Best for | Turo-only fleets of 3+ cars optimizing cost | 1–2 car hosts (from 2 cars) and anyone mixing Turo with direct rental |
Our rule of thumb: Turo-only and 3+ cars → quote Tint first. Two cars, or any direct-rental ambition → quote Roamly first. Then quote the other one anyway, because carshare insurance pricing is young and moves often.
When a local commercial broker beats both
Before Tint and Roamly existed, hosts insured fleets the way every small transportation business does: a commercial auto policy through a local independent broker. That path still wins in specific situations:
- One car. Below both vendors’ minimums, a broker is often the only legitimate option besides parking the car between trips.
- Excluded vehicles. Exotic, salvage-history, or high-value cars that platform products decline can often be written on a standard commercial policy.
- State quirks. In a few states the platform products are thin or unavailable; brokers know which local carriers will actually write carshare.
- Bundling. Once you have an LLC, a shop bay, or employees, one broker handling commercial auto + general liability + garage keepers can beat three separate policies.
The trade-off is price and fit: a generic commercial auto policy often runs $150–$300+ per car per monthbecause it is priced for cars that drive all day, not cars that sit between guests. If a broker quotes you triple Tint’s rate, that is not a scam — it is a product mismatch. Bring the vendor quotes to the broker and let them try to beat the number.
Deductible strategy by fleet size
Your real exposure is the sum of both windows: the earnings plan’s damage responsibility during trips, plus the off-trip deductible you picked. The mistake we see is optimizing each in isolation until a single bad week can hit both. Think in terms of cash reserve per car. Start with what each plan puts on your cash; the middle column adds a $1,000 off-trip deductible, a placeholder figure (yours depends on your quote) to show the combined exposure:
| Plan | You pay first, per claim | Plus a $1,000 off-trip deductible | What the step up buys |
|---|---|---|---|
| More peace of mind | $250 | $1,250 | Baseline: you keep 70% of the trip price |
| Balanced | $1,500 | $2,500 | +10 points of share for +$1,250 per claim |
| More earnings | $2,750 | $3,750 | Another +10 points for another +$1,250 per claim |
The trade is the same at each step: 10 more points of share for $1,250 more damage responsibility per claim. On a car that books $1,000 of trip price a month (an illustrative figure, not a benchmark), 10 points is $100 a month, so one claim large enough to hit the higher damage responsibility — $1,500 or more going from More peace of mind to Balanced, $2,750 or more going from Balanced to More earnings — wipes out about 12.5 months of that upgrade ($1,250 ÷ $100). Put another way, the step up breaks even at $12,500 of trip price per claim. We cannot tell you how often your car will have a claim, and we are not quoting any frequency here: that number is yours to track. Turo lets you set a different plan on each car, so the mixes below are literal. What follows is our judgment as working hosts, not advice:
| Fleet size | Sensible structure | Why |
|---|---|---|
| 1 car | More peace of mind ($250) + broker off-trip policy, lowest deductible you can afford | No fleet cash buffer — one claim is your whole business. Giving up 10 points of share caps an in-trip claim at $250 ($1,250 with the example $1,000 off-trip deductible). Balanced only makes sense if you could write a $1,500 check, plus the deductible, without flinching. |
| 2 cars | More peace of mind on both + Roamly, moderate off-trip deductible | You qualify for Roamly at 2 cars. Reserves are still thin: with $250 of damage responsibility, an off-trip deductible up to about $750 keeps one bad week at or under $1,000. Balanced alone ($1,500) is already over that line. |
| 3–5 cars | Balanced on cars with a booking track record, More peace of mind on new or weak ones; Tint (or Roamly if direct rental), GPS on every car | Tint's 3-car minimum unlocks. Telematics rates + utilization discount reward exactly what a tight fleet already does. Hold one cash reserve that covers a Balanced claim plus your deductible ($1,500 + $1,000 = $2,500 in the example) before moving any car up a plan. |
| 6+ cars | Mix of Balanced and More earnings on proven cars + higher off-trip deductibles; reserve of at least $2,750 plus your deductible ($3,750 in the example), growing with the fleet | With real reserves, taking on more damage responsibility and self-insuring small claims can beat paying for it in share and premium — but only car by car: a step up pays only if the car books enough trip price between claims (the $12,500 break-even above), so track it per car. |
The pattern: as reserves grow, you gradually stop paying — in share or in premium — to have someone else absorb small claims, and keep the money instead. But that only works if you actually know your per-car numbers — which car carries which policy, what each premium does to that car’s margin, and when each policy renews. A vehicle maintenance trackerthat also holds each car’s insurance and registration renewal dates, with email reminders ahead of them, covers that last part.
Where insurance meets your P&L
Insurance is typically the second-largest fixed cost per car after depreciation, and it is the one hosts most often track fleet-wide instead of per car — which hides the economy car whose premium quietly eats a third of its margin. We built FleetGrowfor exactly this kind of bookkeeping: each car carries its own expense history, so premiums land in that car’s P&L, and renewal alerts fire before a policy lapses — because an uninsured week in the off-trip window is precisely the risk you just paid this whole article to avoid. If you are still choosing your first car and plan, start with our guide to starting a Turo business. For the fee and payout side of the picture, see our overview of how Turo works for owners.
Your first 2 cars are free forever on FleetGrow— log each car’s premium, set the renewal date, and you will never discover a lapsed policy from a claim denial.
Frequently asked questions
Do I really need off-trip insurance for my Turo car?
If the car does anything besides sit in your driveway between trips — you drive it to the car wash, deliver it to a guest, move it for street cleaning — yes. Personal auto policies almost universally exclude commercial use, and carriers routinely cancel policyholders they discover hosting on Turo. Turo's earnings plan only covers the trip window, so without commercial off-trip coverage an accident between trips can land entirely on you.
What does Tint off-trip insurance cost, and who qualifies?
As of October 2026, Finder lists Tint's liability-only plan from about $56 per month per vehicle and plans that add physical damage from about $89 per month; Tint's own page now sends US hosts to a quote in the Turo host portal, so treat those as starting points. You need at least 3 vehicles listed on Turo to qualify, Tint isn't offered in New York or Kentucky, and the coverage applies while the car is listed, between trips, for hosting-related use. Connecting an approved GPS tracker within 60 days keeps you on the cheaper telematics rates.
What does Roamly Carshare cost, and who qualifies?
As of October 2026, Roamly advertises Carshare coverage as low as $59 per month per vehicle (liability coverage only; it varies by state and other factors) for fleets of 2 or more cars, with no upper fleet cap. Unlike Tint, its between-trip coverage works with any platform or your own direct rentals, which is why hosts building their own booking channel tend to choose it; on-rental coverage for direct rentals is a separate Roamly product. Roamly requires a connected telematics device within 30 days.
Can I just keep my personal auto policy and not mention Turo?
That is the most expensive shortcut in this business. Misrepresenting commercial use gives the carrier grounds to deny a claim and rescind the policy — meaning you pay the loss and lose the coverage. Hosting also shows up: carriers see claim patterns, mileage, and in some states carshare-platform data. Buy coverage that is actually written for what you do.
If I buy Tint or Roamly, do I still need Turo's earnings plan?
Yes — they cover different windows. Your Turo earnings plan (More peace of mind, Balanced, or More earnings) provides up to $750,000 in third-party liability and a contractual reimbursement for eligible physical damage above your damage responsibility ($250, $1,500, or $2,750 per claim) during trips. Tint and Roamly cover the time between trips, when Turo's protection does not apply. You need both layers; neither replaces the other.
How does a GPS tracker lower my insurance cost?
Off-trip insurers price partly on how much the car actually drives outside of trips. A connected GPS device proves your off-trip mileage is low, which is why Tint reserves its lowest rates for vehicles connected to an approved tracker within 60 days, and Roamly asks for a telematics device within 30 days. A ~$70–90 device plus $8/month is routinely cheaper than the premium difference it unlocks.